Starting coral restoration sooner or when will it be too late…?

by    DiveSSI    27th February 2018
1 Collecting elkhorn coral spawn, photo SECORE International -  Reef Patrol
Photo by ©Paul A. Selvaggio
3 Dr. Margaret Miller, SECORE's Research Director during field work, photo SECORE International
4 Glowing coral recruit, photo SECORE International - Reef Patrol
5 Caribbean reef at its best, photo SECORE International - Paul Selvaggio
6 Monitoring coral cover, photo SECORE International

Many of us have witnessed with our own eyes
the threats coral reefs are facing today: pollution and destruction of reefs, coral
, the
subsequent death of reefs and so on. And we know, while climate change
continues to raise seawater temperatures,
a coral's life is not getting any easier.
Consequently, as coral cover decreases, the number of potential parents to
produce new offspring for compensating the losses decreases too. This not only
reduces genetic diversity of coral populations, but also, as distances between
parental colonies increase, natural
more challenging. There are reefs in the Caribbean where some coral populations
cannot reproduce on their own anymore. Active
coral restoration
may get more and more important to give at least some
coral reefs a fighting change to see the next century.

A recent study led by SECORE's
Research Director Dr. Margaret Miller (published in 'CORAL REEFS') investigated
this topic in the Florida Keys. Margaret Miller is a renowned coral reef
ecologist who worked for NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric
, U.S)
for almost two decades before she joined SECORE last year. She is one of THE coral
restoration experts in the Caribbean and is a passionate diver too, who fell in love with coral reefs when she was
still a child.
In the following interview Margaret Miller explains how the findings of her
study affect coral restoration efforts.

Question: How are corals in the Florida Keys

Margaret Miller: The reefs in the Caribbean have lost more than
90 percent of their corals in the last four decades, mostly due to thermal
stress, which causes bleaching and diseases. We watch corals dying, especially
in the Florida Keys, which is the worst-case area that we currently have in the
Caribbean. Here the reefs are so depleted that we already have some species
which are not naturally reproducing at all.

Q: How do changing environmental conditions
affect reproduction of corals in particular?

MM: As we realize more and more, there are two
additional reproductive challenges emerging when population density is getting
very low. One of them is asynchrony in coral spawning, the other is too low
genetic diversity to allow successful fertilization of eggs and sperm.

Q: Corals often spawn in so-called mass
spawning nights
(; are corals
not keeping their rendezvous anymore?

MM: For coral spawning, we are talking about a
time window of only a few hours, where eggs can be successfully fertilized,
meaning only those individuals, which spawn in close proximity within that
single night window have the potential for producing offspring. Under those
conditions it becomes a real challenge for reproduction, if the few parents,
which are left in a reef, spawn at different nights, as for instance the
elkhorn coral Acropora palmata is known for in the Florida Keys. In this
case fertilization of eggs is very unlikely.

Q: ...and corals need to be genetically
different to reproduce successfully, right?

MM: Yes, to reproduce successfully, coral species
such as the elkhorn coral need spawning individuals that are genetically
diverse. But that is not always the case, since branching corals also reproduce
through natural fragmentation. If for instance a storm hits a reef, fragments
may break off from a colony, get attached to the reef right next to its
parental colony and grow into a new colony. However, both colonies are genetic
clones and cannot reproduce sexually. So even though I may see 50 colonies
growing on a reef, it may be only one or two genetic individuals, which may
prevent sexual reproduction at all. Furthermore, we were particularly
interested looking into fertilization compatibility of individual parents. As
you can imagine, if I only have two or three parents on a reef instead of 100,
it becomes very important, if certain of those combinations are not effective
in producing offspring. And that is what
we investigated in this study for the Mountainous Star Coral Orbicella
and the Elkhorn Coral Acropora palmata.

Q: How does this affect coral restoration
efforts, in particular any concept working with sexually derived coral babies,
such as SECORE’s coral restoration strategy?

MM: There are two important facts we have to
consider. One is, if we restore coral populations we need to have as many
parents available in a local population as we can, because not all of them are
going to be successful in creating larvae. We need to fight for genetic
diversity. The more genetic individuals we can keep on a reef, the higher are
our chances for a successful natural sexual reproduction. The second
implication is that we really want to implement coral restoration before the
population gets as low as it is nowadays in the Florida Keys. Coral restoration
becomes more challenging once you get to this low point
where spawning synchrony or fertilization steps become added challenges. We
want to keep coral populations at a level where those processes are not kicking
in. Therefore we need to start restoration sooner.

Q: Does this imply that each reef manager also
needs to be an expert in genetic analysis to be able to take care of the reefs?

not. If we start soon enough before the population in a certain area or reef is
so depleted, it becomes much less crucial to have that fine scale information.
In many of the places, for example Curaçao, where SECORE has done so much work,
the populations there still are very successful and fertilization rates have
been very high for many species. So, it is something to be concerned about but
another reason to start restorations efforts sooner, where you don’t have to
worry so much about those fine genetic aspects of our population.

If you want to learn more about corals and the fantastic underwater world then check out our ecology programs.

Dr. Carin Jantzen
Communication and Public Relations
SECORE International, Inc.
Paul Selvaggio (2 images)
Reef Patrol (2 images)
Secore International (2 images)

Written by
27th February 2018

The post has no comments.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I confirm

Also by DiveSSI